
"Equivalent grade" is one of the most dangerous phrases in steel procurement. Two grades can have the same yield strength, the same carbon range and still not be substitutable, because one requires impact testing and the other does not, or one is killed and fine-grained while the other is not.
Here is a working comparison, and the places where you should not treat the numbers as permission.
The common pairs
| EN | ASTM | JIS | GB | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S235JR | A283 Gr.C | SS400 (approx.) | Q235B | Yield match, impact differs |
| S355JR | A572 Gr.50 (approx.) | SM490A | Q345B | A572 has no mandatory impact test |
| S355J2 | A572 Gr.50 + Charpy | SM490B | Q345D | J2 needs −20 °C impact; A572 base spec does not |
| S275JR | A36 | SS400 | Q275 | A36 has a tensile range, not a yield minimum in the same way |
| P265GH | A516 Gr.60 | - | Q245R | Pressure vessel, different design allowables |
| P355NH | A516 Gr.70 | - | Q345R | Same warning |
| 304 | S30400 | SUS304 | 06Cr19Ni10 | Practical equivalence |
| 316L | S31603 | SUS316L | 022Cr17Ni12Mo2 | Practical equivalence |
Where equivalence breaks
Impact testing. S355J2 and A572 Gr.50 are routinely treated as interchangeable. They are not, unless the A572 is ordered with supplementary Charpy testing at the required temperature. A designer specifying S355J2 has chosen a low-temperature material; A572 without impact data does not deliver that.
Pressure vessel grades. P265GH and A516 Gr.60 both work at elevated temperature, but the allowable stress tables, the permitted chemistry ranges and the testing requirements differ between EN 13445 and ASME VIII. A substitution changes the design calculation, and that is an engineering decision, not a purchasing one.
Killed vs rimmed steel. Older GB grades were available in rimmed (沸腾钢) form; S235JR is always killed. For anything welded or dynamically loaded, only killed, fine-grained steel should be accepted, regardless of what the strength table says.
Delivery condition. "S355J2" says nothing about whether it is as-rolled, normalized or TMCP. The same grade in different conditions has different toughness and different weld behaviour. Always specify +N or +AR.
How to use a comparison table properly
- Compare the full requirement set, not just yield. Strength, impact, chemistry, delivery condition, testing and certification.
- Write the substitution into the contract if you accept one, with the supporting test requirements. Verbal agreement on "equivalent" is worthless at the inspection stage.
- Ask for both certificates if you are substituting - the original and the proposed - and have your engineer confirm the design still works.
- Do not substitute on pressure or lifting equipment without written design approval.
How we supply against mixed standards
Buyers frequently have a European drawing, a Chinese fabricator and an ASTM-based inspector on the same job. That is exactly where substitutions go wrong, so we handle it explicitly:
- We read the specification clause, not just the grade name, and quote the grade plus the delivery condition and testing that satisfy it
- Where a Chinese GB grade is genuinely equivalent, we say so and provide the comparison basis; where it is close but not equal, we say that too
- Certificates are issued to the standard in the contract - if your contract says EN 10025-2, we do not ship a GB/T certificate with an EN translation
- For projects with multiple standards, we can supply a single consolidated comparison sheet for your engineer to sign off before production
Send us the drawing and the standard list. We will come back with the actual grades we can offer, what testing they carry, and where the gaps are.
Related products: Hot rolled products, Structural steel sections, Fasteners
Related reading
Frequently asked questions
Is S355J2 the same as A572 Gr.50?
Only if the A572 is ordered with supplementary Charpy testing at minus 20 C. The base A572 specification does not require impact testing.
Can Q235B replace S235JR?
They are close on strength and both are killed steels, but the certification and testing requirements differ. Confirm the substitution in writing.
Are pressure vessel grades interchangeable?
No. Allowable stress tables and testing requirements differ between EN 13445 and ASME VIII, so a substitution is an engineering decision.


