Hot Dip Galvanizing or Zinc-Rich Primer: Choosing Structural Protection
Both protect steel with zinc, both are specified on structural drawings, and they are not interchangeable. The difference is where the zinc sits and how long it lasts.
What each one actually is
Hot dip galvanizing immerses the finished steel in molten zinc at about 450 °C. The coating is metallurgically bonded, typically 45 to 85 µm thick (Z275 equivalent conditions vary by standard), and it protects the steel sacrificially - including at cut edges and drilled holes.
A zinc-rich primer is a paint containing 65 to 85% zinc dust by weight. It is applied cold, cures as a film, and protects mainly by galvanic action between the zinc particles and the steel. It is thinner, usually 60 to 80 µm dry film, and it depends on adhesion rather than alloying.
Where the decision turns
| Situation | Better choice |
|---|---|
| Outdoor structure, 20+ year life, no maintenance access | Hot dip galvanizing |
| Large fabricated assemblies that will not fit a kettle | Zinc-rich primer |
| Site-welded joints to be coated on site | Zinc-rich primer (galvanizing burns off at the weld) |
| Coastal or chemical environment | Galvanizing, or a duplex system (galvanized + paint) |
| Aesthetic finish required | Paint over galvanizing or primer |
| Thin sheet and hollow sections | Galvanizing, provided venting is designed in |
The detailing that decides whether galvanizing works
Galvanizing fails where the design does not let zinc in and air out:
- Venting and draining holes in sealed hollow sections, minimum 10 mm, positioned so no air pocket forms
- No overlapping surfaces that trap pickling acid
- Weld slag removed before dipping, or it shows through the coating
- Distortion allowance for thin sections - the 450 °C dip can warp light members
A fabricator who has not galvanized before will often miss the venting, and the parts come back with bare patches inside.
Comparing cost honestly
Galvanizing has a higher setup cost per piece but a low cost per m² of protection and effectively zero maintenance. Zinc-rich primer is cheaper to apply on small runs and repairs, but it needs a topcoat in aggressive environments and has a service life of roughly 10 to 15 years in C3 environments, against 25+ for galvanizing.
How we handle protection
We quote the coating system as part of the supply, not as an afterthought:
- Hot dip galvanizing to EN ISO 1461, with coating thickness measured and reported per batch
- Zinc-rich primer systems specified with the dry film thickness and the topcoat
- Venting and draining checked against the drawings before fabrication, not after
- Cut edges and site welds flagged so the erection crew knows what needs repair coating
- Duplex systems (galvanized plus paint) quoted with the correct pre-treatment
Send the drawings and the intended service life. We will tell you which system meets it, and where the detailing needs changing before the steel is cut.
Related: Galvanized coil, Structural steel sections, Z275 vs AZ150
Frequently asked questions
How long does hot dip galvanizing last?
Typically 25 years or more in C3 environments; 10 to 15 years for a zinc-rich primer with topcoat.
Can galvanized steel be welded on site?
Yes, but the coating burns back and the weld zone must be repair-coated with a zinc-rich product.
Why do galvanized hollow sections need venting holes?
So zinc can enter and air can escape during dipping. Without them the inside stays bare and the part can distort.
